Looking back at 2009 we thought useful to highlight some of the most heated discussions and lengthy debates which we have had over the year within our Linkedin group. Islamic Finance in the News
Islamic Markets on Twitter
8.12.09
LinkedIn Discussions - Highlights of 2009
Looking back at 2009 we thought useful to highlight some of the most heated discussions and lengthy debates which we have had over the year within our Linkedin group. 6.12.09
26.11.09
Can Bursa Malaysia’s Suq al-Sila’ (Commodity Murabahah House) Resolve the Controversy over Tawarruq?
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Asyraf Wajdi Dusuki, Head of Research Affairs Department, ISRA
ISRA Research Paper (No. 10/2010)
"In 2009, Bursa Malaysia launched a new trading platform called Suq al-Sila’ or Commodity Murabahah House. It was introduced to facilitate certain Islamic financial transactions, particularly commodity murabahah based on tawarruq. This platform is claimed to provide genuine commodity transactions where possession and delivery of the commodity can take place without any hindrance, as opposed to the controversial widespread form of tawarruq that uses platforms like the London Metal Exchange (LME). This paper discusses the practice of tawarruq using Bursa Malaysia’s Commodity Murabahah House. In particular the paper comprehensively examines the debates over tawarruq which eventually lead to the OIC Fiqh Academy’s declaration that organized tawarruq is impermissible. This paper concludes that despite the criticisms and some unresolved Shari‘ah matters entangling the practice of tawarruq, the effort made by Bursa Malaysia to introduce a platform such as Commodity Murabahah House is commendable. Furthermore, since the nature of modern organized tawarruq may not strictly comply with Shari‘ah principles, the reasons behind using this facility should be carefully taken into consideration, especially situations of real urgency and cases of need."
Can Bursa Malaysia’s Suq al-Sila’ (Commodity Murabahah House) Resolve the Controversy over Tawarruq?
22.11.09
Financial Stability: The Significance and Distinctiveness of Islamic Banking in Malaysia
Financial Stability: The Significance and Distinctiveness of Islamic Banking in Malaysia Financial Stability: The Significance and Distinctiveness of Islamic Banking in Malaysia
18.11.09
The New Mainstream: Islamic Private Equity and Competitiveness
Is Islamic private equity under-rated or over-sold? Untapped or ill-deployed? There is very little data available on the viability, success (or for that matter failure) of current and previous efforts in this space. While advertorial in nature, this piece suggests a variety of opportunities are available due to three key factors: Demand, Means and Support. However it suggests that in order to activate this there are four challenges faced by the industry: Standardization, Engineering, Education and Human Capital.The New Mainstream: Islamic Private Equity and Competitiveness
Seera Investment Bank
November 2008
The New Mainstream: Islamic Private Equity and Competitiveness
16.11.09
CW: Socially Responsible Investments in Germany, Switzerland and the United States : An Analysis of Investment Funds and Indices
Adopting and Measuring Customer Service Quality in Islamic Banks
Adopting and Measuring Customer Service Quality in Islamic Banks: A Case Study of Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad Adopting and Measuring Customer Service Quality in Islamic Banks
14.11.09
3rd IFSB Public Lecture on Financial Policy and Stability
3rd IFSB Public Lecture on Financial Policy and StabilityIn conjunction with the 15th Meeting of its Council, the Islamic Financial Services Board (IFSB) is organising its 3rd Public Lecture on Financial Policy and Stability on 23 November 2009 in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Bank Negara Malayia (BNM) is kindly hosting both the Meeting of the Council and the Public Lecture.
Mr. Paul Koster, Chief Executive of Dubai Financial Services Authority, and Mr. Jean Pierre Sabourin, Chief Executive Officer, Malaysia Deposit Insurance Corporation will speak in the Public Lecture, which is scheduled to be held at 1:30pm – 5.15pm.
You can view the downloadable programme at the IFSB website. Should you wish to attend the both the Public Lecture and the High Level Conference, or either one of these events, please fill up the online registration form, or email/fax in your details to the IFSB Secretariat.
For more information contact:
Ms. Puteri Bahrun
Email: puteri@ifsb.org
Tel: + 603 2698 4248 ext: 114
3rd IFSB Public Lecture on Financial Policy and Stability
12.11.09
Islamic Finance - Podcasts & Webcasts
Here we feature a collection of educational multimedia materials (both video webcasts as well as audio podcasts) offered by the CFA Institute. This provides an opportunity to learn about various concepts of Islamic finance, topics include structuring sukuk, corporate governance, and the role of standard setting bodies in Islamic finance (this is also complemented by various introductory pieces as well). The list of experts includes Professor Rodney Wilson, Shaykh Yusuf Talal DeLorenzo, Rushdi Siddiqui, Professor Simon Archer, Professor Rifaat Karim, Richard de Belder, and Mohammed Amin (among others).This list will expand in the near future as they plan to add new webcasts periodically. Similarly we plan to highlight much more multimedia content in the near future.
These webcasts are available for free but a registration is required for non-members of CFA Institute (creating an account to login will be created instantly).
With thanks to Usman Hayat for his assistance with the materials.
Islamic Finance - Podcasts & Webcasts
10.11.09
DFSA - Enhancing Clarity and Accessibility of Islamic Finance Rules
Consultation Paper No. 66 Enhancing Clarity and Accessibility of Islamic Finance RulesThe DFSA is proposing to restructure the rules relating to Islamic finance to better promote the visibility and accessibility of the DFSA's regulatory regime (as it applies to Islamic financial activities conducted within the DIFC).
Comments and feedback can be sent to (note deadline is December 4th):
Dhammika Amukotuwa
Associate Director, Policy and Legal Services, DFSA
Email: DAmukotuwa@dfsa.ae
The relevant files are as follows:
Consultation Paper in PDF Format
Appendix 1 — Proposed New IFR Module
Appendix 2 — Sample of a Virtual Handbook
DFSA - Enhancing Clarity and Accessibility of Islamic Finance Rules
8.11.09
The Future of Takaful: Potholes in the Streets of Gold?
The Future of Takaful: Potholes in the Streets of GoldThe Future of Takaful: Potholes in the Streets of Gold?
6.11.09
CW: Socially Responsible Investment Screening: Strong Evidence of No Significant Cost for Actively Managed Portfolios
Bernell K. Stone, John B. Guerard, Jr., Mustafa N. Gultekin, Greg Adams
June 2001
CW: Socially Responsible Investment Screening: Strong Evidence of No Significant Cost for Actively Managed Portfolios
Islamic Banks and Wealth Creation
Prof. Dr. Abdul Ghafar Ismail
ISRA Research Paper (No. 9/2010)
"This paper aims to examine how Islamic banks create wealth: how customers as depositors invest their money through the banks; how the banks invest the funds at their disposal; and how economic agents such as individuals, firms and government use these funds. It also examines how this money generates profit, which is then distributed to Islamic banks and depositors, and hence preserves and develops the wealth (mal) of economic agents. It also raises the larger question of whether Islamic banks contribute to the well-being of society by focusing on return to depositors and to shareholders."
Islamic Banks and Wealth Creation
30.10.09
CW: Socially Responsible Investing in the Global Market: The Performance of US and European Funds
Maria Ceu Cortez, Florinda Silva, Nelson Areal
February 2009
CW: Socially Responsible Investing in the Global Market: The Performance of US and European Funds
27.10.09
Opalesque Islamic Finance Intelligence - Fourth Issue
We are back after a month filled with journey (the OIFI team has been travelling of late: Malaysia, Jordan, UK, UAE and more to come) and correspondingly our fourth installment incorporates content from all corners of the globe. We begin by exploring the potential synergies available across the industry (and whether it is in need of a catalyst to spur further growth and collaboration) in our editorial piece.Complementing this is our Featured Resource section which outlines a variety of country and regulatory perspectives on Islamic finance, exhibiting how approaches can differ widely from one country to another. While some of it is positioning, they are testament to the importance being placed on Islamic banking and how regulators are hard at work trying to address and incorporate it into their existing financial architecture.
Nevertheless this is not just a case of mere talk--what is transpiring beyond the boardrooms of IFIs is in fact very energetic discourse that is gradually developing into a tangible initiative. There is great expectation that this can take the shape of an industry-wide effort (resilient to commercial interests) and one which we look forward to reporting in the near future. Indeed we explore the roots of this initiative in our Discussion Board as we borrow the topic from our online forum: 'Does Islamic Finance Need a Voice'.
In this edition OIFI dives deep into multiple asset classes: The Featured Structure section tackles Islamic REITs and the apparent underutilization of liquid real estate products. Khalil Khoury of KIPCO Asset Management Co. provides his perspective on the investable universe of Shariah compliant products in the Allocator Interview section. We further investigate what might be in store for indexation products in our Fund Manager Interview, as we converse with Saeid Hamedanchi of Florentez Investment Management. To round it out, our Industry Snapshot profiles the latest research undertaken on Islamic equity funds, as we hear from the team of Andreas Hoepner, Hussain Rammal and Michael Rezec.
Further expanding on his Lex Islamicus column, Khalil tackles arbitration and enforcement in Islamic contracts - with particular relevance on the revitalized sukuk market. On the other hand, Nikan surveys the various currents of thought on existentialism in Islamic finance under the Opinion Column - with a compendium of views that are not only contrary to the mainstream but possibly test the resolve of Islamic Bankers. But what doesn't kill us makes us stronger.
As always, we welcome your comments & suggestions (you can also feedback directly to the authors), and we remind our registered readers that you have free access to the entire archive of Opalesque Islamic Finance Intelligence (including back issues) and Opalesque Islamic Finance Briefing (our daily news summary), an ever-growing historical data bank of industry news and articles.
Opalesque Islamic Finance Intelligence - Fourth Issue
20.10.09
CW: Socially Responsible Investing and Management Style of Mutual Funds in the Euronext Stock Markets
New LinkedIn Subgroups
As our Linkedin group has continuously expanded (well over 2,700 members and more than 200 relevant discussions) we have launched smaller subgroups to allow for more focused interaction between like-minded members (we recognize Linkedin requires registration but it is free and very useful in many other respects). We now have four subgroups that cater to the following themes:New LinkedIn Subgroups
17.10.09
Takaful: Concepts & Practise

Takaful: Concepts & Practise
16.10.09
Islamic finance: a recent history with France, a longstanding history with its banks
This paper from the Reims Management School provides a wide overview of the "breakthroughs, challenges and opportunities" faced by the Islamic finance industry in France. It delves into a historical review and an overview of French institutions already involved in Islamic financial transactions. Most importantly it delves into various current issues such as the Fiscal & Legal adjustments being sought. With thanks to the author for providing the paper.Islamic finance: a recent history with France, a longstanding history with its banks
Ghassen Bouslama, PhD.
Professor of Finance, Reims Management School
July 2009
For our francophone readers: La finance Islamique: une recente histoire avec la France, une longue histoire aves ses banques
Islamic finance: a recent history with France, a longstanding history with its banks
14.10.09
Critical Appraisal of Shari'ah Issues on Ownership in Asset-based Sukuk as Implemented in The Islamic Debt Market
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Asyraf Wajdi Dusuki, Head of Research Affairs Department, ISRA & Shabnam Mokhtar, Researcher, ISRA
ISRA Research Paper (No. 8/2010)
"Sukuk comprise one of the fastest-growing segments of the Islamic debt capital market. This paper aims to shed light on Shari‘ah issues that arise in asset-based sukuk structures and operations. It first discusses the concept of sukuk and delineates the difference between asset-based and asset-backed sukuk. It then discusses Shari‘ah issues with regards to ownership (qabd). From the analysis of case studies conducted, three major issues were identified in the operation of asset-based sukuk. They are sukuk-holders’ interest in the underlying assets, restrictions on asset disposal, and due diligence regarding sukuk assets. The paper concludes that restriction of the right of disposal poses a serious doubt whether asset-based sukuk structures truly comply with Shari‘ah principles. Furthermore, the coupling of this restriction of disposal with the purchase undertaking at par effectively turns sukuk into a debt instrument. Hence the paper suggests that there is a need to move towards asset-backed sukuk that clearly fulfils the Shari‘ah requirement. Nonetheless the paper recognizes that the current legal framework impedes the issuance of asset-backed sukuk. Instead of making overnight changes to the sukuk market, the paper highlights the need for all stakeholders to come together and thoroughly discuss measures needed for a transition to an improved market."
Critical Appraisal of Shari'ah Issues on Ownership in Asset-based Sukuk as Implemented in The Islamic Debt Market
12.10.09
Islamic Mutual Funds' Financial Performance and Investment Style
This particular study scrutinizes the performance of Islamic funds with much more comprehensive data of the existing universe of investment products and at the same time delving deeper into the implications of the data. While some of the conclusions would have been voiced within the industry, this study provides much more solid evidence to support/substantiate them.Islamic Mutual Funds' Financial Performance and Investment Style: Evidence from 20 Countries
Andreas G. F. Hoepner (1), Hussain G. Rammal (2) & Michael Rezec (1)
(1) School of Management, University of St. Andrews, UK
(2) International Graduate School of Business, University of South Australia, Australia
Abstract: "We contribute to the investment literature by pursuing the first sophisticated, large scale analysis of a strongly growing mutual fund type: Islamic funds. Despite hundreds of Islamic funds exist the few previous studies investigate the financial performance of less than 60 and the investment style of 6 funds. Based on unique data access, we analyse the financial performance and investment style of 262 Islamic equity funds from twenty countries. We develop a (conditional) three level Carhart model to simultaneously control for their exposure to different national, regional and global equity markets and investment styles. Our findings are fourfold. First, Islamic funds from eight (mainly western) nations significantly underperform their international equity market benchmarks, while funds from only three nations do the opposite. Second, Islamic funds generally prefer small stocks but have no preference for other investment styles. Third, Islamic funds from the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) or Malaysia neither significantly underperform nor clearly prefer small stocks. These three findings have some theoretical appeal, as Islamic funds’ investment universe is limited to Shari’ah law compliant companies, which are more likely small and present in economies with a higher density of Muslims. Fourth, we find some evidence that Islamic equity funds exhibit a hedging function, as their investment universe is limited to low debt/equity ratio stocks."
With thanks to Andreas Hoepner for providing the paper.
Islamic Mutual Funds' Financial Performance and Investment Style
10.10.09
Islamic Finance: What leaders do differently
This piece is far more concerned with branding and positioning of Islamic banks in the context of competing side by side with conventional institutions. Not surprisingly items such as product innovation and 'quick' Shariah approval process are prime considerations, among other things. The question remains - does the need to compete vis-a-vis conventional players makes IFIs drift away from their original business model, instruments, and practices??Islamic Finance: What leaders do differently
Lessons learned from Islamic financial institutions in the GCC
Islamic Finance: What leaders do differently
8.10.09
The Question of an Islamic Futures Market
The Question of an Islamic Futures Market
(Apologies, original link is broken!)
Seif I. Tag El-Din
Markfield Institute of Higher Education, Leicester
IIUM Journal of Economics and Management 12, no.1
The Question of an Islamic Futures Market
6.10.09
Does Islamic Finance Need a Voice?

Does Islamic Finance Need a Voice?
An industry association?
A lobby group?
A vehicle to aggregate efforts and derive change?
A repository of frustration that nobody listens to?
A pat-in-the-back flag-waving exercise?
Clearly much to discuss - in particular a base agenda - but certainly there is a need for some sort of communication channel with the industry as a whole. Your ideas and comments are welcome.
Does Islamic Finance Need a Voice?
4.10.09
Do Islamic Banks Have Greater Market Power?
Time and again we hear about how Islamic banking has proven to be on par with conventional banking (whether that is good is another discussion!), here we profile a recent paper that provides a similar conclusion although it uses a far more technical (and substantiated) approach.Do Islamic Banks Have Greater Market Power?
27.9.09
Marketing Strategy of Islamic Banks

Marketing Strategy of Islamic Banks
25.9.09
Islamic Capital Markets: Products, Regulation and Development
Islamic Capital Markets: Products, Regulation and Development
24.9.09
Islamic Capital Market Products - Developments & Challenges
Abstract: "The development of Islamic capital markets is integral part of development of capital markets in general. Such markets are essential for efficient resource mobilization and allocation. It is more so in an Islamic economy because prohibition of interest implies greater reliance on equities and asset based financing.
Islamic Capital Market Products - Developments & Challenges
20.9.09
18.9.09
Eid Greetings
Hari Raya Eidul Fitri, Maaf Zaher dan Batin!
From the Islamic Finance Resources Team
Courtesy CommentsGuru.com - Forward This Image
Eid Greetings
17.9.09
A Note on Islamic Economics
A Note on Islamic Economics
15.9.09
KPMG: Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance
A broad overview by KPMG on Islamic finance, worth noting Section 3 which outlines a variety of barriers to entry - amongst them the ever increasing gap in Human Capital and (very current in recent headlines) the need for regulatory and legal frameworks. Also page 13 talks about Women in Islamic Finance, highlighting various industry voices on the challenges faced. While this particular piece dates back t0 2007, it seems that many of the key challenges are still present to this day and some remain unaddressed.KPMG: Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance
13.9.09
Sukuk and their Contemporary Applications
This particular piece sparked an industry-wide debate on the day-to-day practice of various sukuk structures (mainly murabaha and musharaka versions). For a short review of the paper and its market implications also check this short brief from Norton Rose. Among other things Taqi Usmani goes on to discuss 'The Higher Purposes of Islamic Economics', but mainly he focuses his attention on these three key points:1. Bond Holders' Ownership of Enterprise Assets
2. Regular Distributions to Sukuk Holders
3. Guaranteeing the Return of Principal
Sukuk and their Contemporary Applications
Muhammad Taqi Usmani
President of the AAOIFI Shariah Council
2007
Sukuk and their Contemporary Applications
10.9.09
CW: Investing in Socially Responsible Mutual Funds
Christopher Geczy, Robert F. Stambaugh, David Levin
October 2005
CW: Investing in Socially Responsible Mutual Funds
9.9.09
Case Study: Islamic Microfinance in Australia
The perspective from downunder is rather different than other periphery markets, but noticeably Islamic finance has been developing through community organizations and grassroots initiatives for quite some time now, MCCA being an example. This paper gives some color to the viability of microfinance and other financing schemes in Australia, particularly interesting as local demand might be small but it proves crucial to the viability of Islamic finance.Islamic Microfinance: A Case Study of Australia
Abu Umar Faruq Ahmad
Professor A. B. Rafique Ahmad
Journal of Islamic Economics, Banking and Finance
August 2008
Abstract: "Microfinance services are commonly viewed for those traditionally considered non bankable. Microfinance tool can be adapted in every environment, based on the local needs and
economic situation. In Australia, Islamic microfinance enterprises that mostly rely on their shareholders’ savings proved to be very successful in providing microfinance to their clientele."
Case Study: Islamic Microfinance in Australia
7.9.09
Islamic Marketing Ethics
Ethics, governance, corporate behaviour, branding - all in all, how does one combine marketing and Islamic finance? On the other hand, what is the level of recognition and validity given by Muslim customers to Shariah compliant investments? How does one determine the level of preference for a compliant solution versus a conventional one? Is there such a preference or is it perceived as a penalty on financial performance? Is there a way to quantify all this? Can this methodology be applied to other services beyond banking products (from insurance & car financing to food, clothing, etc?). A vast topic indeed!This specific piece from KAU provides a good starting point for discussion. Note the original link to the paper is broken, shown here is a mirror link.
Islamic Marketing Ethics and Its Impact on
Customer Satisfaction in the Islamic Banking Industry
Abul Hassan, Abdelkader Chachi, Researcher, Islamic Economics Research Centre, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, and
Salma Abdul Latiff, Director of Centre for Islamic Banking, Finance and Management, University Brunei Darussalam.
With thanks to Joy Abdullah for suggesting the topic.
Islamic Marketing Ethics
6.9.09
Basel II and Regulatory Framework for Islamic Banks
Basel II and Regulatory Framework for Islamic BanksM. Kabir Hassan, University of New Orleans
Mehmet F. Dicle, University of New Orleans
Basel II and Regulatory Framework for Islamic Banks
1.9.09
Opalesque Islamic Finance Intelligence - Third Issue

First of all we would like to extend to all a blessed Ramadan Mubarak. As Muslims around the globe observe the holy month we take this opportunity to pause and reflect on where Islamic finance stands today and what’s in store for the industry’s future. As millions of Muslims reflect, so does the industry ponder on its very own direction, principles and ultimate purpose.
This is barely our third edition, but the feedback can be summarized by one of our readers (a director of an Asian-based investment bank) who put it plainly: “there is some really good stuff in this thing”. We push forward and for this edition of OIFI we begin by addressing what we term the 'Two Schools of Islamic Finance' as we delve into a rather unassuming - although significant - division in opinion on how the practice of Shariah compliance should be approached. Interpretation can have far reaching implications, take for instance the Majallah (the civil code of the Ottoman caliphate) which is regarded as the first attempt to codify Islamic law and remains an important source of reference to the present day.
We follow with one of our most requested items – and a good indicator of industry renaissance – a compilation of Islamic finance training programs and certifications. Thereafter, Nikan tackles a more specific discussion on Wa’d in our Featured Structure section, whereas Khalil delves into a forward looking analysis of Islamic financial instruments and arbitration channels in his Lex Islamicus column. Their perspectives are complemented by additional opinions on the role of the Islamic finance framework in our Discussion Board.
This month’s edition includes a Manager Interview with Dieter Küffer, of Sustainable Asset Management, regarding their Islamic water strategy. Their SRI background is by no means accidental, as our Opinion Column further profiles views on social responsibility and corporate governance from Sayd Farook and Usama DeLorenzo respectively. To round it all out, the spirit of transparency is alive and well in our final piece which explores the rather unusual: products from the graveyard (liquidated, obsolete, dare we say unsuccessful).
Once again we welcome your comments & suggestions, and a reminder that you can check the free online archive of Opalesque Islamic Finance Briefing (our daily news summary) which provides a historical data bank of industry news and articles, as well as the back issues of OIFI. It’s all there, it’s all free.
New subscribers can set up their Opalesque subscriptions here.
Opalesque Islamic Finance Intelligence - Third Issue


